In April 2010, I wrote a post about a Facebook challenge run by Method, the home cleaning products purveyor. They rewarded their fans with a 50 percent discount for reaching their 10,000 fan milestone. Unfortunately, they faced a number of logistical challenges, too, and their wall lit up with complaints.
Last week they ran a similar promotion when they hit 50,000 “likes.” That’s a lot of growth in 16 months.
Unfortunately, it seems Method didn’t learn from its mistakes. While there are plenty of posts of gratitude, there are arguably as many of complaint. The promotion code didn’t work for some. The people in customer service couldn’t help. The list goes on. People are even complaining about why Method isn’t responding to the complaints.
I don’t think any brand should feel obligated to respond to each and every complaint on a Facebook wall. As Jonathan Salem Baskin pointed out in his comment to my last post, people who “like” Method on Facebook may have never spent one cent on their products. But I do think a post to the community that acknowledges the issues people faced and explains the limitations of the promotion is in order.
I also think it wasn’t the most thoughtful approach to issue the promotion on the eve of Hurricane Irene. Method may be based in California, but many of its East Coast customers (myself included) weren’t able to log on to even know about the promotion. Couldn’t they have said they’d make the announcement about the promotion once the hurricane subsided?
Maybe the third time will be the charm.